Solving a dispute with the help of artificial intelligence

  Updated on  26 October 2026

When you find yourself in a dispute with a trader following a purchase, it can be tempting to seek assistance from AI. Particularly when the dispute is cross-border and you are unfamiliar with the language or legislation of the other country, an AI agent can quickly provide you with initial information. But how much credibility should you place in its legal advice? To what extent can you trust a chatbot to help resolve your dispute? In the legal field, AI is a limited tool. It is sometimes more appropriate to seek help from dedicated professional bodies.

Middle-aged man working from home-office on laptop
Artificial intelligence can, for example, help you structure your claim, but it should not be your sole legal guide. © Adobe Stock

Can AI become your legal adviser?

No. Using AI can be useful for gaining a better understanding of your rights in Europe in general, identifying certain rules that may apply to your situation, or helping you prepare a complaint. In theory, it can explain the difference between certain rights or help you spot important clauses in a contract. It can even suggest a template letter to send to a trader.

However, a convincing answer from AI to a legal question is not necessarily an accurate one.

Legal answers are not always reliable

Many AI systems can, in fact, produce incomplete information or generate ‘hallucinations’. They may invent false references, statutory provisions or court rulings that do not exist, or cite rules that are no longer up to date. Furthermore, AI does not necessarily always have all the relevant information to provide a comprehensive legal answer, especially in a cross-border context.

Even a very detailed query does not guarantee a reliable answer. This is particularly true in cross-border disputes, where the choice of the applicable law (which national law applies) is crucial. AI can provide guidance, but the final assessment must be left to professionals. They will be looking for the small details that may make all the difference.

An answer that appears accurate, cites a section of legislation and suggests a course of action is not necessarily reliable. An error may go unnoticed and lead you to take inappropriate action, pursue an unsuccessful claim or even waste time or money.

Treat AI as an assistant rather than a legal adviser

Use AI to help you understand your rights and prepare your case. But check key details before taking any action. For specific legal queries, rely on official sources and the relevant authorities.

Do not provide sensitive data (full contact details, identity documents, bank details, etc.) directly to the AI. Only add this information once you have copied and pasted the generated text into the email or contact form intended for the trader.

Find out how to protect your personal data online

Should you use AI to prepare your complaint?

Customer service and complaints departments, as well as consumer advice, mediation and reporting services, currently receive a very large number of enquiries. These enquiries are often prepared or drafted with the help of AI. To ensure your claim is processed efficiently, it must therefore be clear, concise and, if possible, ready for immediate action. A well-structured claim helps it stand out and avoids unnecessary back-and-forth correspondence that prolongs processing times.

Prepare a separate chronological summary

When making a complaint to a trader, avoid at all costs lengthy summaries or timelines buried amongst copies of documents in a single file. Opt instead for a separate, concise chronological summary outlining the key stages: purchase of the product or service, problem encountered, steps taken, responses from the trader and/or any other significant recent developments.

Don’t simply ask the AI to summarise all your correspondence and documents. Take ownership of your case: determine for yourself the facts underlying the complaint, the key dates, the requests made and the responses received, as well as the relevant documents. AI can help you structure your complaint, but it is up to you to select the elements that are genuinely useful for understanding the dispute.

Above all, avoid inserting copies of your documents, screenshots or supporting evidence into the body of your claim summary. This type of integration makes analysis more complex. It sometimes requires the documents to be broken down again and can therefore significantly lengthen processing times.

Stick to the facts

If you use AI to draft or reword your complaint, read it through carefully. AI may add accusations, legal characterisations or very strong wording that you did not express yourself or whose validity you cannot guarantee. For example, avoid certain terms such as ‘scam’ or ‘fraud’. Opt for neutral wording, for example: ‘the product delivered does not match the description’ or ‘the trader has not responded to my enquiry’. An accurate, neutral and verified summary facilitates analysis and strengthens the credibility of your complaint.

Organise and number your supporting documents

Attach your documents in separate files, organised by category and in chronological order. Name each document clearly and, if possible, assign it a number, for example: ‘Document No. 1 – Invoice dated [date]’. Then include this numbering in a list at the end of your chronological summary to allow for quick identification of the documents referred to.

Weigh up your claims

If the AI suggests you claim damages or a goodwill gesture in addition to a refund or the fulfilment of the contract, take the time to think it over. Such a claim may be legitimate if you have genuinely suffered a loss. However, it is not always necessary, nor justified.

In an out-of-court settlement, systematically requesting additional compensation can sometimes deter the trader from a simple solution, such as a refund of the principal amount or the proper performance of the service owed. You should therefore assess the actual loss suffered and the proportionality of your claim before adding it to your complaint.

Concerning possible claims for compensation for physical, moral or other non-pecuniary damages, such claims cannot, unfortunately, be settled out of court through the European Consumer Centres Network (ECC-Net). It is necessary to initiate legal proceedings so that a judge, following an expert assessment, can quantify the damages based on evidence of the harm, causality and the other relevant elements.

Check the purpose of each organisation

If the AI suggests contacting several organisations, first check the purpose of each one. Is it a reporting body, an information service, a consumer organisation or a mediation service or ADR-body?

Can you approach these organisations at the same time, or does one procedure preclude the other? When seeking an amicable resolution, it is generally not possible to pursue several similar courses of action simultaneously. This can even be counterproductive. For example, you might approach an ECC and a separate ADR or mediation service at the same time regarding the same dispute, however they most often cannot intervene in parallel towards the same trader. Find out for yourself beforehand about the scope of the organisation you wish to approach, its eligibility criteria and the applicable procedure.

Tailor your case to the recipient

The same dispute may be presented differently depending on the recipient. The points to emphasise, the wording of your request and the supporting documents to attach may differ depending on whether you are contacting the trader, an ADR of mediator, a consumer organisation or ECC, or a regulatory authority for the sole purpose of reporting the matter. Therefore, before sending your case, check what the recipient expects. Tailor your summary accordingly, without altering the facts.

Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are however those of the author(s) only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Innovation Council and Small and Medium-sized Enterprises Executive Agency (EISMEA). Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them.